St Louis Cardinals Fan Site

What are the Odds?: What are the Chances the Cardinals make the Postseason, and what to potentially watch for in the Offseason

  Albert Pujols

St. Louis Cardinals' Albert Pujols reacts as he stands on third base after teammate Matt Holliday hit a single during the third inning of a baseball game against the Cincinnati Reds, Saturday, Sept. 3, 2011, in St. Louis. Pujols scored later in the inning. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)

In the midst of much jubilation over beating the Milwaukee Brewers in a mid-week three game series sweep, a question begs to be answered; just how much of a chance do the Cardinals actually have?
The answer, while obvious to most who’ve paid even a modicum of attention since June,of their chances of competing for a playoff spot, as of now, seems like an insubstantial world of complete unfounded exuberance.
So, how much of a chance is that again?

Well, as of today the Cardinals are on pace to be an 86-win team. Whilst the Brewers are on a 93-win pace. Every year Baseball Prospectus releases a daily annual report which calculates each teams chances of making the postseason, and a calculation of their “expected” win total for that year.
Anyway, this chart, as of today, gives them a 1.5% chance. It ain’t lookin’ good, is it?

I guess now would be a good time to apply the Chicago Cubs’ unofficial franchise slogan of, “Wail ’till next year!”. With that in mind, and little to look forward to for most Cardinals fans; except for Pujols chase for .300/30/100 for the eleventh straight year in succession. Or perhaps want get get an extended look at Brandon Dickson? WatchMatt Holliday reach the twenty home run milestone for the sixth consecutive season, or watch Lance Berkman’s pursuit of his first 100 RBI season since 2008. Or maybe you just love the simple joy of watching the games can provide? All that is left is watch the remaining 23 games, all the while hoping; possibly in vein, that this team could possibly make it. Or if you’re more of a pessimist, I suppose you might already have a keen eye on the quickly approaching off-season–O.K., maybe it’s not as close as I make it seem, but you get the idea. Oh, by the way, ….Speaking of the off-season, it will probably one of the most intriguing off-seasons in recent memory; perhaps in St. Louis Cardinals history…well, one could suppose other events have been of greater magnitude than this, but I digress…. However, I do know this, the Cardinals off-season will revolve around one singular mesmerizing, gravitational force that all of Cardinal Nation can’t but help to succumb to. That force is none other than Albert Pujols; and his upcoming pending Free Agency. Let’s take a flashback somewhat, shall we? Let’s go back to Febuary early to mid-Febuary. A time when the contract negotiations of Albert Pujols and the St. Louis Cardinals were under the scrutiny of every microcosm in the known universe, or so it seemed, anyway. Basically the two sides couldn’t really come to a reasonable agreement with one another over the length and salary demands of Albert Pujols. Fast forward seven months later, and it looks apparent that the Cardinals probably have the most leverage in the possibility of procuring Albert’s services beyond 2011. Most of that leverage has been granted to the Cardinals through Albert’s play this year. How can one argue that a man who puts up numbers like this in a given year .296 .369 .555 .924, including 34 home runs and 85 RBIs to date is not worthy of the contract of his desires? Especially considering what he has done the past ten? The logic is pretty simple: 2011 has not been an atypical year concerning his offensive production. He BB% has taken a hit,( something Albert has alluded to himself as a reason for his struggles earlier) his career average is at 13.2%, while currently he has a 10.1 BB%. His ISO is also down, too, .259, but still performing well against his counter-parts. However, his BABIP has taken a hit(Currently .270; Career .311), as has also his OBP and his OPS, as well. Despite the potential for putting up great numbers yet again in 2011, any slight discrepancy in his numbers will presumably raise a red flag to many teams interested in the soon-to-be thirty-two-year-old first basemen. Which, obviously, will most likely tilt the leverage in the Cardinals favor, or at least one might think.
So, once the dust has been settled from the Albert Pujols conundrum, you’ll get a munch better sense in which direction the Cardinals will head in 2012.
A lot of players will be off the books next year, and a lot of pertinent decisions must be made.
Starting with: Albert Pujols(Who has already been discussed.
Chris Carpenter: He does have a Club Option worth 15 million, but I would suspect the Cardinals to buyout that option, and try to re-work a deal for the backside of Carpenter’s career.
A two to three year deal around 15 to 20 million, that is also heavily incentive laden wouldn’t be too surprising. Maybe a little more, but I wouldn’t suspect too much more than that.
Lance Berkman:By every indication, the possibility of Berkman returning to St. Louis seems to be all but an absolute formality. Another deal similar to last year’s, but with a higher base salary. I would suspect somewhere between 10-12 million on a one or two year deal. Alas, that is purely speculation, of course.
Rafael Furcal: I highly doubt St. Louis has any interest whatsoever in picking up Furcal’s $12 million dollar club option for 2012. He becomes an inriguing part of the equation. Whille offensively the numbers haven’t been great in his time in St. Louis(Although he has looked better the past eleven games: .300 .333 .550 .883; including three home runs and five driven in), there is little denying that he hasn’t helped improve the middle infield, where lack of defensive prowess in that area has crippled the team. As far as Short Stops are concerned on the open market, the pickings are slim indeed. With the most recognizable names being Jose Reyes, Jimmy Rollins,. Hardy would may have probably been the best alternative of possible Free Agents if you’re looking for an offensive upgrade, but the O’s ended all possibility when they extended him for three more seasons at 7.5 million annually. It will be interesting which direction the Cardinals might follow with one less option to look at. Perhaps the trade market might be best, depending on who is available. That, however, remains to be seen.
Ryan Theriot: Ryan was brought in to replace another Ryan to, hopefully, make a more marked improvement offensively; that didn’t happen, at least not as much as the Cardinals had hoped for, especially how much it hurt the team defensively. I suspect the Cardinals in a different direction with Theriot, and have little faith in a return visit for next year. Overall his defensive short-comings couldn’t transcend over what would only be h slight improvement the Cardinals saw on offense. Overall, the trade was a wash.
Skip Schumaker: His defense has been bad enough that even improved offensive numbers can barely produce a WAR of 1.1 for him. It’s time to end this experiment, and go a new direction. However, I do like him as a versatile utility player, and could serve very well on an MLB bench. Certainly a player to at least consider keeping around. That said, the potential list of Free Agents doesn’t really offer that much appeal. I wouldn’t be too surprised if a trade might be worked out, or someone from the system might receive an opportunity. I could see an open competition next year for second base. With Schumaker, Descalso, Tyler Greene(Who has played well, and probably deserves one last shot, but at 28, time is running out), and maybe a ST look at Zach Cox, but I wouldn’t list him as anywhere close to being a front-runner at this point in time.

Moving on………….

To the Bullpen:
You can’t look back on this season and not attribute some of the lack of success due to the failures of the bullpen this year. The bullpen, as a whole; without divulging into the some of the painful numbers they have produced, has been very mediocre throughout most of the season. Especially in the earlier part of the seasons. However, the acquisitions of guys like Dotel and “Scrabble” (See: Rzepczynski, Marc) have solidified the bullpen, and would be very content with the bullpen, but a few pick-ups to further bolster one of their biggest weaknesses of 2011 would certainly increase confidence. Certainly some intriguing names out there, such as Heath Bell, and Johnathon Broxton, to name a few, but don’t look for any type of acquisition like this to become a reality, by any means. Expect more of an acquisition in the form of a well-traveled veteran or two.

A lot of questions to be answered, and a lot depends on the decisions of Albert Pujols. This off-season will more than likely be thedefining moment in John Mozeliak’s tenure as General Manager of the St. Louis Cardinals. A lot of people want to judge a G.M.s’ abilities on how what moves worked, and which didn’t. This off-season will most definitely be the best barometer you’ll ever get to gauge him from, undoubtedly. The question is, will he pass the grade? As always, time will reveal the answers. As will be revealed John Mozeliak’s mettle.

1 Comment to What are the Odds?: What are the Chances the Cardinals make the Postseason, and what to potentially watch for in the Offseason

  1. September 5, 2011 at 5:32 pm | Permalink

    Hello, I believe your internet site could be getting browser compatibility troubles. When I seem at your web site in Safari, it seems to be very good but when opening in Net Explorer, it’s got some overlapping. I just wished to provide you with a swift heads up! Other then that, wonderful web site!

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

RSS Stay up to date on Redbird One’s posts

  • Quest for Middle Infielder Heats Up for the Birds. December 7, 2012
    Per MLB Trade Rumors “The Cardinals want to upgrade with a utility infielder, tweets Jon Paul Morosi of FOX Sports. They’ve discussed free agent Alex Gonzalez and trade options Chris Getz of the Royals and Steve Lombardozzi of the Nationals.” All three potential infielders would make a nice fit in St. Louis. Alex Gonzalez offers […]
  • Cardinals Off-Season needs are Few, but Still Plenty of Intrigue. December 6, 2012
    While the Off-Season needs are few this year, there is still plenty to divulge into with the Winter Meetings now underway. The needs are relatively simple for 2013. Find some bench help; preferably a right-handed hitter, with some pop, who can play some center-field who can spell Jon Jay every so often. Add a left-handed […]
  • B.J. Upton: Over-Paid? Or Right on the Money? November 30, 2012
    There is a lot that can be said of B.J. Upton. When he was drafted, he was a sure thing; he was a can’t-miss prospect. He was ranked the second-best prospect in baseball, and by age nineteen he had made it into the big-leagues. He was a rising star in the making. Here we are […]
  • Furcal and St. Louis Express Mutual Interest in Possible Return Engagement. September 6, 2011
    Yesterday it was reported by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch that the St. Louis Cardinals and Rafael Furcal have expressed a mutual interest in a return engagement for the 2012 season. While Furcal’s twelve-million dollar option will not be exercised, it’s reasonable to suspect that a deal may fall in place before Furcal hits the Free […]
  • What are the Odds?: What are the Chances the Cardinals make the Postseason, and what to potentially watch for in the Offseason September 5, 2011
    In the midst of much jubilation over beating the Milwaukee Brewers in a mid-week three game series sweep, a question begs to be answered; just how much of a chance do the Cardinals actually have? The answer, while obvious to most who’ve paid even a modicum of attention since June,of their chances of competing for […]
  • Animosity displayed towards Rasmus is unfounded. June 2, 2011
    Ok, I plan on being a lot more active on this site now that I have some free-time. Now that that is out of the way, I just can’t fathom the almost borderline malevolence displayed towards him by a select few, or maybe more than that. Colby Rasmus has been placed with gargantuan expectations from […]
  • Andy Pettite? A Hall of Famer? I’m not sold. February 19, 2011
    …..Nor do I think he should get in five years from now, or beyond, for that matter. However, he may eventually get in someday, but he’s, obviously far from a lock.  Skimming over some of the basic numbers( 240 wins, 3.88 ERA, 2251 SOs), he looks like he compiled a pretty, if not, very good […]
  • Is a Triple Crown Award in the Cards for Pujols in 2011? Bill James thinks so. January 9, 2011
    While 2010 MVP Joey Votto may grace the cover of Bill James’s latest Handbook, but it is another fellow first basemen who is projected to overshadow, well…everyone else on the planet. That player would be none other than Albert Pujols. If you are of the many who scoff at projections, and dismiss them as nothing […]